Brooklyn Pizza Co

4.8

(198 votes)

14a calle 4 oriente antigua, 00000

Open now • Closes at 23:00

Discover the Authentic Taste of New York at Brooklyn Pizza Co in Antigua

Located at 14a calle 4 oriente in the heart of Antigua, Brooklyn Pizza Co offers an exceptional dining experience that captures the essence of classic New York-style pizza. This eatery invites you to enjoy delicious, handcrafted pizzas made with fresh ingredients and perfected with a great crust by owner Greg and his passionate team.

A Perfect Blend of Flavor and Atmosphere

Brooklyn Pizza Co features a casual and pet-friendly courtyard area where guests can relax and savor their meal in a welcoming environment. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick slice or sharing an 18-inch pizza ideal for two, the flavors promise to delight your palate. The standout Goat Cheese pie and the chicken pesto pizza are must-tries, showcasing the innovative combinations that have captured the hearts of locals and visitors alike.

The friendly and personable team not only provides excellent service but also offers valuable insights into the local area, making your visit even more memorable. With a vibrant bar scene, Brooklyn Pizza Co is also a lively place to mingle with travelers, locals, and expats. Open daily from noon until late evening (10 PM on weekdays and 11 PM on weekends), it’s the perfect spot for a casual lunch, a pregame hangout, or a relaxed night out.

Come and experience what many have called the best pizza in town, rooted in authenticity and community spirit that keeps guests coming back again and again.

Reviews Menu

4.8

198 votes

172

Natalia Ledford

July 6, 2025

Pizza was delicious . This place was also fun to go eat at, very casual, pet-friendly courtyard area. Highly recommend.

Angel Valenzuela

July 6, 2025

Excellent service and delicious pizza

Bilal M

June 22, 2025

The nose led the way into this fun restaurant. From the square you can smell the classic new york pizza style, and it did not disappoint.nGreg has spent time honing his craft and it shows.nGreat crust with fresh ingredients all done perfect.nnHis whole team is friendly, personable and the service was excellent.nYou could tell they were loved by locals that kept pouring in to say hi and grab a slice/pie.nnPs. Try the Goat Cheese pie- the flavors were on point!

Tom

May 31, 2025

Awesome pizza! Absolute good combinations and the 18” is ideal for 2 people. We went there 2 times because it was so good. Probably the best value of pizza you can get in Antigua. Try the pesto pizza with chicken !

Randy Kremlacek

May 29, 2025

I learned of this restaurant from a post by the owner Greg Hilchey on a motorcycle forum, offering a free pizza to any motorcyclist passing through Antigua.nnSo, our group of four riders decided to look him up once we got to Antigua. I'm so happy we found Brooklyn Pizza Co. Greg followed through on him commitment and not comp'ed our pizza but bought us drinks. That's the kind of care and love put into this place.nnThe pizza was authentic New York style. Yes, really Brooklyn Pizza in Antigua, Guatemala.nnAnd check out the bar too. When we were there it was a great mix of travelers, locals and expats. So much fun trading stories and laughs.nnRun, don't walk to Brooklyn Pizza.

Brooklyn Pizza Co

Contact

Discover the Authentic Taste of New York at Brooklyn Pizza Co in Antigua

A Perfect Blend of Flavor and Atmosphere

Menu

Other restaurants nearby:

Al Casale GT

Al Macarone • Tipografía

Al Pomodoro Restaurante